Many of us have chosen to follow church leaders we trust. But how do you know you are being shepherded in the right way or are being led astray? What makes good pastors and what makes toxic pastors?
Knowing what to watch for in a church leader is key to creating a healthy, thriving ministry. Some signs show that they are on the right path—green flags that encourage growth and unity. Others are yellow flags, warning you to slow down and evaluate. And then there are red flags—serious issues that demand immediate attention.
In this episode, we’ll explore these flags and what they mean for your leadership and your church. Let’s dive in and learn together!
Estimated reading time: 10 minutes
Table of contents
What is Toxic Church Leadership?
Before we get into the green, yellow, and red flags you may see in church leaders, it’s important to identify exactly what we’re talking about. Why is this so important and why should you care?
What Makes a Church Leader Healthy?
A healthy church leader is humble, caring, and focused on serving others. They lead with integrity, putting the needs of their church members above their own. Healthy leaders communicate clearly, listen well, and encourage growth in their team and congregation.
They build a positive church culture where everyone feels valued and supported. By modeling Christlike behavior, they inspire trust and unity, creating a healthy church environment.
What Makes a Church Leader Toxic?
Toxic leaders are often self-centered, controlling, or manipulative. They use their position for personal gain, ignoring the well-being of church members. Toxic leadership creates fear, division, and mistrust. Unhealthy church leadership often refuses accountability, dismisses feedback, or silences criticism.
These behaviors harm church culture, making it difficult for people to grow spiritually or feel safe. Over time, an unhealthy leader can damage relationships and weaken the entire ministry.
Why It’s Important
Understanding the difference between healthy and toxic leadership is crucial for the health of any church. A healthy church leader helps build a strong, supportive community where members thrive. On the other hand, toxic leadership can hurt individuals and push people away from the church.
Recognizing the signs of toxic leaders allows church members to address problems early, protect their community, and create a church culture that honors God. Healthy leadership isn’t just about avoiding harm; it’s about fostering a space where everyone can grow in faith, love, and service.
Identifying and encouraging healthy leadership ensures the church remains a place of hope and healing for all.
Green, Yellow, and Red Flags
Now it’s time to identify the different levels of health and unhealth in a church leader. Very few people actually take the time to step back and evaluate the church culture they are apart of. Its important to assess our leaders (in grace) so that we can recognize a toxic church culture.
Green Flags
Green flags in church leadership are positive signs of a healthy and thriving environment. They show that a leader is humble, accountable, and focused on serving others.
Green flags include clear communication, respect for boundaries, and a commitment to fostering unity and spiritual growth within the church.
Yellow Flags
Yellow flags are warning signs that something might be off. They don’t always mean immediate harm, but they signal the need for caution and further evaluation. Examples include a leader avoiding feedback, struggling with transparency, or showing inconsistent behavior.
Addressing yellow flags early can prevent bigger problems later.
Red Flags
Red flags indicate serious issues in leadership that require immediate attention. These are signs of toxic leadership, such as controlling behavior, manipulation, dishonesty, or creating division among church members.
Red flags harm church culture and can lead to an unhealthy church environment. Recognizing these signs is crucial to maintaining a strong, supportive community.
Ranking Pastoral Qualities
Now let’s jump into various examples of pastoral qualities a church leader may have. Once we expand on these characteristics or actions, we can then identify if they are a green, yellow, or red flag in a leader. This will help us locate bad church leadership when we find it and avoid any spiritual abuse.
abusive leadership
Accountability
Accountability is a vital pastoral quality that helps leaders stay humble and trustworthy. A pastor who is open to feedback, willing to admit mistakes, and works closely with church staff shows a green flag of healthy leadership. They create a culture where others feel safe and supported.
However, if a leader avoids accountability, dismisses concerns, or isolates themselves, this moves into the yellow flag zone, signaling potential problems. In extreme cases, refusing accountability can become a red flag, showing toxic leadership.
Not all churches prioritize accountability equally, but it’s essential for building trust and maintaining a healthy church environment.
Favoritism
Favoritism in pastoral leadership can harm church culture. Showing equal care for all church members is a green flag, fostering unity and encouraging church attendance. However, favoritism, such as giving certain people special treatment, falls into the yellow flag zone, signaling potential division.
If favoritism leads to neglecting others or creating cliques, it becomes a red flag, damaging relationships and discouraging a healthy church environment. Equality is key to strong leadership.
Gossiping
Gossiping is a serious issue for pastors and can harm church health. Avoiding gossip and promoting honest, respectful communication is a green flag of healthy leadership. However, if a pastor occasionally shares unnecessary details about others, it enters the yellow flag zone, needing caution.
When gossip becomes a pattern, especially to undermine others or protect abusive leaders, it’s a red flag that damages trust and threatens the church’s unity and health.
Silencing
Silencing others is a harmful pastoral quality that can undermine trust. Encouraging open dialogue and listening to different perspectives is a green flag, fostering unity and growth.
If a pastor occasionally shuts people down in favor of speeding things up and keeping things moving, it’s a yellow flag, showing room for improvement. However, consistently silencing feedback, criticism, or concerns is a red flag. This behavior damages relationships, suppresses accountability, and creates an unhealthy church culture over time.
Transparency
Transparency is a key quality for pastors to build trust. A green flag is when a pastor is open about decisions, challenges, and personal struggles, creating a culture of honesty. If a pastor avoids certain topics or is unclear, it’s a yellow flag, signaling potential issues.
In cases of hiding important information or making secretive decisions, it’s a red flag, often linked to abusive leadership, damaging church health and relationships.
Ignorance
Ignorance in pastoral leadership can create serious challenges. A pastor who actively seeks knowledge and personal growth shows a green flag, fostering a healthy church. However, when a pastor ignores feedback or avoids learning, it becomes a yellow flag, signaling potential problems.
In extreme cases, willful ignorance can be a red flag, leading to poor decisions and division. Here are areas where ignorance can cause issues:
- Lack of understanding in scripture or theology.
- Ignorance of emotional or spiritual needs of the congregation.
- Unawareness of church dynamics or leadership strategies.
- Failure to address conflict within the church.
Blaming
Blaming in pastoral leadership can create division and mistrust. A healthy leader takes responsibility for their actions and seeks solutions, which is a green flag. However, if a pastor often shifts blame onto others or avoids accountability, it becomes a yellow flag, signaling poor leadership.
Consistently blaming others for mistakes or failures is a red flag, as it undermines trust and can harm the church’s unity and morale.
Sharing
Sharing responsibility, glory, and information is a key pastoral quality. A green flag is when a pastor openly shares successes with the team, distributes tasks fairly, and keeps the congregation informed. If a pastor hoards glory or withholds important information, it becomes a yellow flag, showing a lack of transparency.
A red flag appears when a pastor takes credit for everything or hides vital information, damaging trust and unity within the church.
Boundaries
Boundaries are crucial for healthy pastoral leadership. A green flag is when a pastor sets clear, respectful boundaries with church members, balancing work and personal life.
If a pastor struggles to maintain boundaries, like overworking or becoming too involved in personal matters, it’s a yellow flag, indicating potential burnout. Red flags arise when boundaries are completely ignored, leading to manipulation, dependence, or unhealthy relationships, damaging the church community.
Overextension
Overextension in pastoral leadership can hurt both the leader and the church. A pastor who takes on too many tasks without delegating or setting boundaries shows a yellow flag, signaling burnout risks and potential inefficiency.
If overextension continues without addressing the issue, it can lead to exhaustion and a decline in church health, making it a red flag. Here are signs of overextending:
- Taking on too many church responsibilities without support.
- Neglecting personal health or family life.
- Failing to delegate tasks to church staff or volunteers.
- Working long hours without rest or balance.
Prioritization
A pastor’s focus and priorities greatly impact a church. A green flag is when a pastor prioritizes spiritual growth, church attendance, and building a healthy community. If their focus shifts to personal goals or minor details, it’s a yellow flag, signaling misaligned priorities.
In a church plant, neglecting foundational needs or focusing solely on numbers is a red flag, as it can harm long-term growth and weaken the church’s mission.
Burnout
Burnout is a serious concern for pastors and affects their leadership. A green flag is when a pastor practices self-care, takes breaks, and knows their limits to avoid exhaustion.
If a pastor starts showing signs of stress or fatigue but continues working without addressing it, it’s a yellow flag, signaling potential burnout. A red flag occurs when burnout takes over, leading to poor decision-making, emotional withdrawal, and neglecting the church’s needs, which can harm the entire ministry.
Toxic Pastors
In conclusion, recognizing the various flags in pastoral leadership—whether green, yellow, or red—is essential for fostering a healthy church environment. Healthy leaders prioritize transparency, accountability, and boundaries, creating an atmosphere of trust and growth.
On the other hand, toxic leadership traits like favoritism, gossiping, or neglecting self-care can damage relationships and harm church health. By being aware of these qualities, both church leaders and members can work together to address challenges early and build a supportive, thriving community.
A strong church culture starts with strong leadership, and with careful attention to these flags, a church can flourish spiritually, emotionally, and relationally. Healthy leadership is key to lasting, positive impact.
We hope these were helpful. God bless!
More Resources on Church Leadership
About The Author
