What is the best online giving service for your church in 2025?
After the popularity of our post The 7 Best Online Giving Companies For Churches, we’ve decided to review each company separately to help you better choose the right one for you, starting with our Tithe.ly review.
In 2025, most churches already know the importance of having an online giving service integrated into their tithes/offerings. The question is: is Tithe.ly the right choice for your church?
Tithe.ly is made specifically for churches and offers a range of giving options to make it easy for your members to give. It has a multitude of features that have made it very popular among thousands of churches all over.
Our Tithe.ly review begins now.
Estimated reading time: 9 minutes
Table of contents
What is Tithe.ly?
Tithe.ly is a dedicated giving tool designed specifically for churches and ministries. It’s easy to customize to your needs and accept one-time or recurring donations.
You can even set it to accept event registrations. With an easy-to-use form, anyone can quickly donate in just a few steps, making it more likely for them to give. The platform is easy for donors to access from most any device, including mobile.
Ease of use, straight-forward record keeping and a branded donation form are just some of the reasons Tithe.ly has become an industry leader.
Main Features
While our Tithe.ly review could easily be much longer if we listed all of Tithe.ly’s features, we’ll just cover the main features that are most relevant to your church.
Two of the most important features of any online giving company is types of payments and security. After all, if payments aren’t secure, people won’t feel safe donating. Tithe.ly allows donors to give via debit card, credit card and bank account (ACH). Plus, payments are encrypted with 256 Bit TSL/SSL. All processing servers are Level 1 PCI-DSS compliant.
Obviously, you want to receive funds quickly. After a one-time seven-day wait period, you can get payments daily that only have a two-day processing time. You can also set up weekly or monthly deposits if you’d like.
Tithe.ly’s giving forms allow donors to set up one-time or recurring payments. You can also customize the forms to accept event registrations, support individual missions and more. This allows donors to give to specific parts of your church if they choose.
According to Tithe.ly, people are six times more likely to give if they aren’t redirected to a third-party site. That’s why you can customize the forms with your church colors and logo. You can even customize the email receipt so donors know they’re giving to your church.
While the form itself is mobile-friendly, you also get a free iOS/Android mobile giving app. People can also give via text or a simple kiosk in your church.
With detailed reports, it’s easy to see what you’re collecting and when. This makes accounting much easier. We wanted to make sure to include this in our Tithe.ly review as we know bookkeeping isn’t always the easiest thing to do.
Pricing And Fees
While you want giving to be more convenient for your members, you obviously don’t want to lose your donations to expensive software and fees.
One of the reasons Tithe.ly is so popular is because the platform and setup are completely free. You only pay a small fee per donation. Text giving does cost $19/month, but you don’t have to add that if you don’t want to.
Every donation is subject to simple fees:
- Credit/debit cards: 2.9% + $0.30
- AMEX: 3.5% + $0.30
- ACH: 1% + $0.30
This is a small price to pay to increase tithing and continue growing your church.
While our Tithe.ly review only covers the online giving part of their service, there are additional plans for further church management. These include everything from check-ins to a media player for your sermons. These are premium plans that are useful, but you don’t have to purchase them to use the highly affordable online giving options.
Tithe.ly Pros
We’ve already broken down a lot of the features that make Tithe.ly a great option for churches, like its main features and pricing options. But what about other things that make it so popular? Let’s get into all the benefits your church gets with Tithe.ly.
QuickGive
Tithe.ly’s QuickGive feature makes donating fast and easy. With just a few taps, users can give without logging in. This is perfect for one-time gifts or for people in a hurry.
QuickGive securely saves payment details for future use, so donors don’t need to enter their information again. Churches benefit by making giving simple and accessible for everyone. The feature supports multiple payment methods, including credit cards and ACH transfers.
It also integrates with Tithe.ly’s reporting tools, helping churches track donations. QuickGive is a hassle-free way to encourage generosity and keep giving convenient for both donors and ministries.
Auto-Recurring Giving
Tithe.ly’s Auto-Recurring Giving makes donating easy and consistent. Donors can set up automatic gifts on a schedule that works for them—weekly, monthly, or any custom timeframe. This helps churches receive steady support without donors having to remember each time.
Setting it up takes just a few taps, and payment details are securely stored. Donors can adjust or cancel their recurring gifts anytime. Churches benefit from predictable giving, making budgeting and planning easier. Auto-Recurring Giving ensures generosity happens regularly, helping ministries grow and thrive without interruption. It’s a simple, stress-free way to stay committed to supporting the church.
Reports and Insights
Tithe.ly’s provides detailed reports and insights to help churches track giving easily. It provides clear, real-time data on donations, helping leaders understand trends and plan better. Churches can see who gives, how often, and which giving methods are used.
Custom reports make it simple to filter and analyze data. The dashboard gives a quick overview, while detailed reports help with financial planning. Churches can also track fundraising campaigns and donor engagement. With these insights, leaders can make informed decisions to grow generosity.
Tithe.ly’s Reports and Insights feature makes church finances clear, organized, and easy to manage for any ministry.
Add-Ons
As mentioned previously, Tithe.ly offers more features for churches who want to pay for them. While none of these are included in the normal free version of Tithe.ly, churches that want these additional options can add them to their subscription.
Add-ons include:
- Church website hosting for $19/mo.
- Church apps for $89/mo.
- Messaging system for $19/mo.
- Integrated church management software for $79/mo.
- Additional worship tools for $29/mo.
Alternatively, churches can pay $119 a month flat for all of these features in a big bundle to save the church time and money.
Tithe.ly Cons
Like everything, Tithe.ly is not a perfect service. There have been multiple (though few) churches that have taken issue with it and its features. While there are certainly more pro’s than con’s for Tithe.ly, it’s still important to address issues you may come across while using the service.
Transaction Fees
One downside of Tithe.ly is its transaction fees. Every donation made through the platform is subject to a processing fee, which can reduce the total amount a church receives. Credit card transactions typically have higher fees than ACH bank transfers.
While donors can choose to cover these fees, not everyone does, meaning churches may lose a portion of each gift. Over time, these fees add up, impacting the overall budget and reducing funds available for ministry and outreach.
Churches need to weigh their options and decide if a monthly paid service is ultimately more sustainable for them than Tithe.ly’s service which is free but takes a percentage of every donation.
Learning Curve
Tithe.ly offers many features, but the platform can have a learning curve. New users, especially those unfamiliar with digital tools, may find it challenging to navigate at first. Setting up giving options, managing reports, and customizing settings may take time to understand.
Church staff and volunteers might need training to use the system effectively. While Tithe.ly provides support resources, some users may still struggle with certain functions, making the transition to digital giving a bit overwhelming at the start.
Bugs
Like any digital platform, Tithe.ly can experience occasional bugs and glitches. Some users report issues like slow loading times, errors in transaction processing, or problems with recurring donations. These technical issues can cause frustration for both church administrators and donors.
While Tithe.ly regularly updates its system to fix bugs, some users still encounter unexpected errors. If problems arise during peak giving times, they may disrupt donations and church operations, making reliable technical support essential for resolving issues quickly.
Final Verdict
Tithely is a powerful giving platform that helps churches manage donations, track finances, and engage donors. Its features, like QuickGive, Auto-Recurring Giving, and Reports & Insights, make giving simple and accessible.
However, there are some downsides, including transaction fees, a learning curve, and occasional technical bugs. While it offers great tools, churches may need time to adapt and manage potential challenges.
Overall, Tithely is a strong choice for churches looking to modernize giving, but leaders should weigh the costs and technical aspects to ensure it’s the right fit for their ministry’s needs and long-term financial goals.
Because of all this, we have given Tithe.ly the title of Best Online Giving Company For Most Churches.
Want more church online giving provider reviews? Check out our complete list of the best online giving companies.
More Resources on Online Giving
About The Author
Comments 1
i so much appreciate your down to earth information on the various options. Seems honest and straight forward.