2026 Edition · Top 100
Matthew Everhard
Pastor · Gospel Fellowship (PCA) · United States
Matthew Everhard reaches 107K followers on personal accounts across YouTube, Instagram and Facebook, ranking #39 on REACHRIGHT's 2026 Pastor Influence 100. The largest single audience is YouTube, at 91.2K subscribers.
Score Breakdown
Personal accounts only · data collected August 15, 2026 · methodology
Platform Presence
What counts
Four platforms are scored: YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook. Only accounts the pastor operates count here. Church-branded accounts are scored separately in the Church Influence 100.
X (listed, not scored): @matt_everhard
About Matthew Everhard
Matthew Everhard is the pastor of Gospel Fellowship Presbyterian Church, part of the Presbyterian Church in America, in South Butler, Pennsylvania. He holds a Bachelor's degree in Bible from Malone University, a Master of Arts in Practical Theology from Ashland Theological Seminary, and a Doctor of Ministry from Reformed Theological Seminary in Orlando, where his dissertation examined Jonathan Edwards's theology of joy.
Everhard is a Jonathan Edwards scholar and adjunct professor at the Reformed Presbyterian Theological Seminary in Pittsburgh. He is the author of Holy Living: Jonathan Edwards's Seventy Resolutions for Living the Christian Life, published by Hendrickson in 2021, and Souls: How Jesus Saves Sinners, published by Icthus Publications in 2022. His writing has also appeared with Desiring God, Modern Reformation, and Gentle Reformation.
Everhard's YouTube channel carries 91,200 subscribers, up 23.2 percent this year, the base of his 107,302 combined reach across three platforms.
The Church Behind the Platform
Pastor
Gospel Fellowship (PCA)
United States
Gospel Fellowship (PCA) is not ranked in the 2026 Church Influence 100. The two indexes measure different things: one scores church-branded accounts, this one scores the pastor's own.
A personal following is a trust account. People follow a name, hear a voice, and decide what to believe about the church behind it. That is a weight to carry well, not a scoreboard to win.
Is this you?
You made the 2026 Pastor Influence 100. Add the badge to your site or your church's staff page and link it back to this profile.
Click the code to select it, then copy.
Matthew Everhard: Quick Answers
Who is Matthew Everhard?
Matthew Everhard is the pastor of Gospel Fellowship Presbyterian Church, part of the Presbyterian Church in America, in South Butler, Pennsylvania. He holds a Bachelor's degree in Bible from Malone University, a Master of Arts in Practical Theology from Ashland Theological Seminary, and a Doctor of Ministry from Reformed Theological Seminary in Orlando, where his dissertation examined Jonathan Edwards's theology of joy.
How many followers does Matthew Everhard have?
As of June 2026, Matthew Everhard reaches 107K followers across personal accounts: 91.2K YouTube subscribers, 8.2K Instagram followers, 7.9K Facebook followers. These figures count accounts the pastor operates, not the church's official accounts.
What church does Matthew Everhard pastor?
Matthew Everhard serves as Pastor of Gospel Fellowship (PCA) in United States.
Is Matthew Everhard still the pastor of Gospel Fellowship (PCA)?
At the June 2026 data collection, Gospel Fellowship (PCA) listed Matthew Everhard as Pastor. We report leadership exactly as each church publishes it, and the index is rebuilt every year. Check the church's own site for the current staff listing.
Where does Matthew Everhard rank among the most influential pastors online?
Matthew Everhard ranks #39 on the 2026 REACHRIGHT Pastor Influence 100 with an Influence Score of 66.6 out of 100, scored on audience reach (50 percent), growth velocity (30 percent), and platform breadth (20 percent).
How fast is Matthew Everhard's audience growing?
The YouTube channel Matthew Everhard runs grew 23 percent in the twelve months before June 2026, reaching 91.2K subscribers. That measured growth scores 75.5 out of 100 on the velocity pillar, which is 30 percent of the Influence Score.
How does your church compare?
Check your Church Influence Score
Matthew Everhard scored 66.6 on personal reach. See where your church stands, scored against churches your size, not the megachurches. Free, and about a minute.
See Your Church Influence Score