You’ve uploaded sermons. You’ve got a decent logo. You tell people to subscribe at the end of your videos. But for some reason, your church’s YouTube channel just isn’t growing.
No views. No comments. And no momentum.
And you’re not alone. Most churches on YouTube are stuck in neutral, wondering what they’re doing wrong, while other channels seem to take off overnight.
But the truth is, your church’s presence on YouTube doesn’t have to stay stagnant. Whether you’re a church plant or a long-established community, you can start reaching more people with the message of Jesus Christ by making a few smart and intentional changes.
Let’s break down the biggest mistakes churches make on YouTube and the top strategies you can use to grow your audience and create videos that actually make an impact.
Estimated reading time: 7 minutes
Table of contents
Why YouTube Matters
In 2025, YouTube is more than a place to watch funny clips or music videos. It’s one of the largest search platforms in the world. With over 2 billion logged-in users every month, it’s where people go to learn, explore, and discover.
Churches like Elevation Church with Steven Furtick or Life.Church with Craig Groeschel are reaching millions with the gospel every week. It’s not just because they’re big, but because they use the platform with purpose.
Here’s the good news. You don’t have to be a megachurch to succeed on YouTube.
You just need a strategy.
If your church’s YouTube channel is going to reach people, build community, and share the gospel, it needs more than just good intentions. It needs a plan that works with the platform and speaks to real people.
7 Top Church YouTube Mistakes
Here is a list of the top 7 most common church YouTube mistakes. These mistakes were found through research and by observing common patterns among church YouTube channels. We’ll break down each mistake you might be making with your channel and exactly what you can do to fix them.
Let’s jump into it.
1. Your Titles Aren’t Searchable
This is one of the most common reasons church channels stay invisible.
Titles like “Faith Part 2” or “Sunday Sermon August 12” might mean something to your congregation, but they mean nothing to the person browsing YouTube looking for answers about anxiety, purpose, or God.
If your titles aren’t specific and searchable, your videos will not show up. And if they do show up, no one will click.
Fix it:
Write titles that reflect what people are searching for.
Bad:
“Unshakable Part 4”
Good:
“How to Trust God When Life Falls Apart”
Use questions, bold statements, and real-world language. This change alone can significantly increase your views.
2. Your Thumbnails Don’t Grab Attention
Your thumbnail is your first impression. If it’s just a blurry screenshot of your pastor mid-sentence, it is not going to perform well.
People scroll quickly. Your thumbnail needs to catch their eye and make them curious.
Fix it:
Create custom thumbnails with large text, high contrast, and expressive faces. Make sure your thumbnail and title work together to communicate a clear message.
A good thumbnail can often be the difference between 100 views and 10,000.
3. You’re Only Uploading Full Sermons
Posting your entire worship service every week is fine, but it should not be your only type of content.
Most people on YouTube are not looking to watch a 50-minute video. They want something short, relevant, and impactful.
Fix it:
Pull clips from your sermons and post them separately. These can be 60-second YouTube Shorts, 5-minute story clips, or focused answers to common questions.
Short-form content helps you reach more people, increases engagement, and leads new viewers to your full messages later.
4. You’re Ignoring the YouTube Algorithm
YouTube decides what to show users based on the information you give it. If you upload a video with no description, tags, or chapters, the algorithm has no clue what your video is about.
Fix it:
Spend a few minutes optimizing your uploads:
- Write a thoughtful description using words like gospel, worship, Jesus, faith, and church
- Add 5 to 10 relevant tags
- Create chapters in your sermons so people can skip to the part they want
- Include a clear call to action, such as “Subscribe for weekly faith-building content.”
The more information you give YouTube, the better it can share your videos with the right people.
5. You’re Not Promoting It Anywhere Else
Many churches post their videos on YouTube and then hope people find them. But if you are not promoting your channel on other platforms, most people will never see your content.
Fix it:
Promote every video you upload:
- Mention your channel during your Sunday announcements
- Share links in your email newsletter
- Post clips on social media
- Embed videos on your church website
- Ask your church members to like, comment, and subscribe
- Encourage viewers to leave comments, likes, or feedback on your videos to boost engagement
YouTube success starts with your existing community. Get them involved in sharing the message.
6. You’re Not Connecting With Real People
YouTube is not just about content. It’s about connection.
If your videos feel distant or overly polished, they might miss the heart of ministry. People are not just looking for information. They are looking for authenticity, emotion, and hope.
Fix it:
Encourage your pastors to speak directly to the camera. Use stories. Be honest. Be human.
Think of each video as a personal message to one person who needs encouragement, truth, or comfort. That kind of content connects and keeps people coming back.
7. You’re Not Consistent
One of the biggest reasons church YouTube channels fail to grow is a lack of consistency. If you upload randomly or only post once a month, it’s hard for the algorithm and your audience to trust your channel.
Fix it:
Create a simple content rhythm:
- Post a full sermon every Sunday
- Upload one or two Shorts midweek
- Use a recurring theme, such as “Testimony Tuesday” or “Friday Devotional”
Consistency builds trust. Trust builds community.
Even small churches can create regular content that reaches people far beyond their local zip code.
Level Up Your YouTube Channel
You don’t need a massive budget or a full media team to grow your church’s YouTube channel.
What you need is clarity, consistency, and a desire to serve real people with meaningful videos.
The goal is not to become the next Elevation Church or match the polish of Craig Groeschel’s team. The goal is to help someone meet Jesus, grow in faith, and feel like they are part of your church’s community, even if they’re watching from the Philippines.
The internet is full of distractions. But it’s also full of people searching for hope, truth, and connection. Your church has something powerful to offer, and YouTube is one of the best tools to share that message.
So get smart. Keep learning. Try new things. And most importantly, keep showing up.
The gospel is still changing lives. Your videos might be the invitation someone has been waiting for.
More Resources on Church Social Media
