8 Church Marketing Mistakes to Avoid at All Costs

Stephanie Hodges Uncategorized Leave a Comment

If you think church marketing is challenging, you’re not alone. It can be difficult to find the right balance in marketing that’s effective and cutting-edge but still feels authentic to your church’s mission and culture. 

But you don’t need to settle, and if you avoid the top mistakes churches make in their marketing, you’ll be on the right track.

This blog post will discuss eight church marketing don’ts you should avoid at all costs. These honest mistakes can be deadly to your marketing results over time. And to wrap up, we’ll cover some church marketing best practices to help you reach people the right way.

Estimated reading time: 10 minutes

8 Church Marketing Don’ts to Avoid

Churches can fall into one of two extremes in their marketing efforts: either they’re desperate to chase the latest trends, or they don’t do anything, and their church becomes irrelevant.

In addition, what works in one church might not work in another, and what works today might be outdated by tomorrow. It’s easy to fall into some of the marketing mistakes we’ve outlined below, but we’ll discuss how to avoid them and what to do instead to build your church marketing strategy.

1. Don’t say yes to everyone all the time.

Anyone who works in a church knows that you have multiple ministries, events, and priorities vying for advertising space. Your team is filtering an avalanche of incoming requests, and it can be challenging to say no to these good causes.

But broadcasting every event and ministry can be overwhelming for people. And it also sends the message that you’re insider-focused.

Someone not currently attending your church won’t understand the lingo or how they fit into the picture.

Your church marketing team has limited time, resources, and money. So it’s essential to be strategic about what gets announced (as well as when and where you communicate it).

Key question: Is our marketing strategy based on our audience’s needs or our internal demands?

2. Don’t spread yourself too thin.

You have limitless opportunities to be creative, from traditional marketing to internal projects to digital strategies. However, nobody has the resources to maximize every single channel, so you must pick and choose wisely.

And while you need a well-rounded church marketing strategy, if you charge forward with unrealistic expectations, you have a recipe for disaster. It will be difficult to avoid team burnout and frustration on all ends.

Spreading yourself too thin leads to subpar results across the board. It’s better to focus on a few church marketing initiatives and do them with excellence than try to tackle everything and end up with mediocre results.

Key question: What marketing channels are most effective and are we focused on those, or have we taken on too much?

3. Don’t use cheesy or over-the-top marketing tactics.

We’ve all seen corny commercials before. They’re often memorable because they are cringey. But you never want to make people feel like they’re being sold to or manipulated.

Although the saying, “there’s no such thing as bad publicity,” may hold true for some businesses and industries, we can’t say the same for churches.

When people look for a church (even if they’ve never stepped foot in one before), they want a safe place with trustworthy people. Nobody wants to risk their spiritual health and family’s well-being!

So, although a gimmicky marketing tactic may catch their attention, it won’t necessarily earn their trust – that’s where the wrong style of church marketing can backfire on you. In addition, you don’t want to make any false promises, or people will be disappointed when they walk through your doors.

Key question: Are we marketing out of desperation to get noticed or authentically representing our church family?

4. Don’t be afraid to try new things.

Even though we just talked about avoiding cheesy gimmicks, that doesn’t mean you shy away from trying new techniques, styles, and content. As a general rule, churches tend to lag in creative and innovative marketing.

Thinking “out-of-the-box” is not the same as being “over-the-top,” although we can get confused between the two and err on the side of being overly cautious.

Also, if you’re terrified of failure, you’ll get stuck playing it too safe and using old, tired techniques.

When you try new things, you won’t get it right 100% of the time; part of the cost of innovation is the occasional flop. But remember, if you’re not trying to improve and stay fresh, you’ll fade into the background noise.

Key question: How often are we trying something new in our marketing strategy?

5. Don’t neglect the basics.

An exciting aspect of church marketing is that there’s always a brand-new tool, platform, or strategy to utilize.

But don’t neglect your foundations. Church marketing fundamentals like solid branding, a well-designed website, local search engine optimization (SEO), and consistent email communication will always be necessary. They may not be as flashy, but they work.

If you don’t have these church marketing basics in place, no amount of bells and whistles will make up for it. And if you have an outdated website or you’re inconsistent in your marketing communication, then people will be frustrated.

Key question: Do we have solid and excellent church marketing basics in place?

6. Don’t let your social media feed become an event bulletin board.

Why do people use social media? While staying updated and informed is one primary reason people use social media, finding funny and entertaining content is equally important to users. According to the Digital Report 2021, other reasons people use social media include

  • Filling up spare time
  • Staying in touch with friends
  • Networking
  • Meeting new people
  • Sharing photos or videos

As you can see, social media is all about relationships. So, as a church, if you’re only talking about yourself and your events, you’re missing the point of being social.

Your church’s social media strategy should provide valuable content that is inspiring and helpful to people. Otherwise, they’ll scroll on by to find something that serves them.

Key question: Are our social media feeds about what we want from people or what they want to see?

7. Don’t ignore accountability.

When you’re spending time and budget on marketing, it’s a huge mistake to be vague about your goals and performance.

Operating without a strategy and clearly defined budget is simply poor stewardship. Your church marketing efforts can’t be feelings based or change on a whim.

And part of being accountable means measuring your progress and tracking the right metrics so you can determine what’s working and where you need to make adjustments.

Maybe you’re dumping money into Facebook ads and getting a poor ROI. You need to choose a different strategy, get help, or push pause, so you’re not dumping money down the drain.

Key question: Do we have clear goals and track the right metrics?

8. Don’t feel guilty about marketing.

We know businesses have to market themselves, but what about churches? You may wonder if it’s biblical and ethical because it sounds strange to combine the words “church” and “marketing.”

But the purpose of church marketing is to find effective ways to share the good news of Jesus Christ with those who need to hear it. It’s not about selling a product or becoming rich and famous.

Consider your motives and goals, and find language to express those genuinely – that’s what church marketing is all about!

Key question: Are we holding back from reaching more people because of incorrect mindsets around marketing?

5 Church Marketing Principles to Put Into Place

Now that you know some common church marketing pitfalls to avoid let’s focus on some tips you can take action on for a church marketing plan for growth.

1. Be strategic with your yes.

Before you can start saying yes or no to marketing channels and requests, you must put a plan and strategy in place.

  • What are your church’s mission and core values?
  • Who is your target audience?
  • What are the goals of your leadership team?
  • What channels are most effective for your particular church?

Once you know the answers to these questions, you can focus on marketing opportunities and where to invest your time.

Next, you need to make sure everyone understands the strategy and guidelines. For example, maybe you only use social media ads for events that have the goal of reaching an external audience.

Or you specify what information you’ll share on social media main feeds, and what you’ll share in stories.

Having these kinds of policies takes the guesswork out of planning and helps your colleagues and church leaders understand where and how they can communicate.

2. Be truthful and sincere

Sometimes, it’s tempting to make your church marketing mirror the big church down the street with lots of followers. Or try to appeal to as many people as possible.

But if you’re not being authentic, you’re not doing anyone any favors.

When you’re honest about who you are and what you believe, people can make an informed decision about whether or not your church is right for them. And if they do visit, they know what to expect because your marketing accurately tells the story of who you are.

So be yourself. Also, try to use original photos and videos instead of stock footage whenever possible.

Building an authentic brand is a more effective long-term strategy than catching peoples’ eye momentarily.

3. Be creative

It’s ok to borrow ideas or see what’s working for other churches for inspiration. But don’t stop there; take another creative step.

Your church is unique, and your marketing should reflect that. You have the opportunity to stand out and connect with people in a way that feels fresh and new. They don’t want carbon copies of what they’ve already seen from hundreds of other churches.

Take time to brainstorm and look beyond churches to see what innovative businesses and marketing agencies are doing.

Also, remember that creativity takes many forms beyond artistic expression. Consider creative options for your strategies and tactics as well as your content.

4. Utilize keywords and SEO

SEO, or search engine optimization, is the practice of optimizing your website and content to rank higher in search engine results. Social media platforms also use keywords and SEO to determine which content to show users.

When you’re creating church marketing materials, be mindful of the keywords and phrases people might use to search for a church like yours. Use those keywords throughout your website and social media platforms to help people find you more easily.

People may not be familiar with Christianese phases or technical theological terms, and that’s not what they’re searching for. For example, people are much more likely to search for a phrase like “need marriage help” than they are “sanctification in marriage.”

Research which keywords and phrases are most popular in your area and church demographic, and use those in your church marketing.

5. Build a team

Digital marketing is getting increasingly complicated. And if you’re trying to do it all yourself, you will feel overwhelmed and frustrated.

Your church marketing team doesn’t have to be huge or only include staff. You can build a volunteer team to help with things like

  • Photography
  • Social media
  • Graphic design
  • Website maintenance
  • Video production
  • Research
  • And more

Look for people with a passion for creativity and who are willing to learn and grow. You can also look for church members with experience and skillsets in these areas.

Finally, consider the advantages of partnering with other churches or outsourcing. Of course, not every church can afford its own web developer. But you can find someone to do contract work for a much lower cost than hiring someone full-time.

Conclusion

Church marketing is vital for any church that wants to reach new people and grow. But it’s not always easy to get started or know what to do. You can set your church up for success by avoiding these church marketing don’ts. And by following the tips in this blog post, you’ll be well on your way to building an effective church marketing strategy.

What are some other church marketing don’ts you would add to this list? Share your thoughts in the comments below!

More on Church Marketing

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.